Upper Orwell Crossings: Tender Evaluation Scoresheets

Discussion in 'Upper Orwell Crossings' started by Upper Orwell Crossings, Jul 20, 2017.

  1. Upper Orwell Crossings

    Upper Orwell CrossingsNew Member

    Messages:
    6
    Location:
    Ipswich Waterfront
    Due to a Freedom of Information request, this is an ideal insight into how RIBA architecture competitions work.

    A curious understanding how these competitions are run and how a firm can go from shortlist to winner. The minimum specifications as per the tender have to be met to stand a chance - all shortlisted architecture firms are likely to have met this to get shortlisted.

    The decision is weighted over two methods:
    1. 40% is financial (commercial in confidence, only Suffolk County Council sees this), and
    2. 60% is 'quality' through a 'Tender Evaluation Scoresheet'
    The evaluation criteria is as follows:-

    2017-05-31 - 14848 - QB Reply Data (1)(5)-1.png

    The scoring system for the competition (quality) is as follows:-

    2017-05-31 - 14848 - QB Reply Data (1)(6)-1.png

    The Tender Evaluation Scoresheets for the shortlisted architecture firms are as follows:-
    1. Adamson Associates with William Matthews Associates and Ney & Partners
    2. Foster + Partners
    3. Knight Architects with MRG Studio
    4. Marc Mimram
    5. Wilkinson Eyre with FHECOR and EADON Consulting
    Kind of Suffolk County Council to share these. It is a shame they are not released as protocol for both transparency and educational reasons, so the public knows how the tender process works for large public projects. I have certainly learned a lot!
     

    From Ipswich? Join the Ipswich Community today!

    Get involved in the online Ipswich Community to enter our competition to win £250.
    We would love to hear your views on this topic. Read the T&Cs.


    • Common discussions include the economy, local politics, Northern Bypass, unitary authority, homelessness, Upper Orwell Crossings, crime, and potholes.
    • Comment on Ipswich Star news articles without strict moderation

  2. Loading...


More like this

 
Title
RepliesViews
Last Message
  1. dan5

    Ipswich Vision: In A Nutshell

    by dan5 in Ipswich Democracy GroupUpper Orwell CrossingsJul 12, 2017 with 2 replies and 77 views.

  2. dan5

    Leaked: Actual Ipswich Cornhill End Designs Revealed

    by dan5 in Local PoliticsUpper Orwell CrossingsDec 10, 2017 at 10:38 PM with 13 replies and 135 views.

  3. dan5

    Upper Orwell Crossings: December Update

    by dan5 in Upper Orwell CrossingsUpper Orwell CrossingsDec 12, 2017 at 9:18 PM with 2 replies and 25 views.

  4. dan5

    Cornhill Regeneration scheme rockets to £3.6m after cost saving changes

    by dan5 in Local PoliticsUpper Orwell CrossingsDec 10, 2017 at 11:12 PM with 8 replies and 95 views.

  5. dan5

    Suffolk Highways: 1 in 10 posts vacant

    by dan5 in Local PoliticsUpper Orwell CrossingsDec 12, 2017 at 6:41 PM with 2 replies and 22 views.

  6. dan5

    Ben Gummer

    by dan5 in Local PoliticsUpper Orwell CrossingsApr 15, 2017 with 68 replies and 237 views.

  7. dan5

    Ipswich Buses refuse to serve Ransomes Europark

    by dan5 in Local PoliticsUpper Orwell CrossingsDec 1, 2017 with 2 replies and 84 views.

  8. dan5

    Sick Joke: Central Suffolk MP Dr Dan Poulter off ill

    by dan5 in Local PoliticsUpper Orwell CrossingsNov 30, 2017 with 2 replies and 102 views.

  9. dan5

    The Ipswich Proposal

    by dan5 in Local PoliticsUpper Orwell CrossingsJun 29, 2017 with 12 replies and 164 views.

  10. hciwspi

    Central Suffolk MP Dr Dan Poulter sticks hands up female MP skirts

    by hciwspi in Local PoliticsUpper Orwell CrossingsNov 5, 2017 with 3 replies and 148 views.

Loading...

Share This Page